✨ PRE-LAUNCH EDITION★GET FIRST DIBS ON BATCH 01★DENVER, COLORADO★BLACK TEA + WHOLE DESI SPICES★YOUR AMMA WAS RIGHT★✨ PRE-LAUNCH EDITION★GET FIRST DIBS ON BATCH 01★CALL YOUR AMMA
← Back to Amma Says
UNSOLICITED ADVICE

“Why Are You Buying That In A Coffee Shop For Seven Dollars?”

A cultural critique of syrup pumps vs real crushed cardamom, and why your friends deserve better when they come over.

By Amma Herself•2 min read•October 2, 2026

I am not mad at the coffee shop. I go to the coffee shop. The people are nice, the music is fine, and sometimes a person simply needs a place to sit that is not their own kitchen. This is not an attack. This is a concerned observation from someone who has watched you pay seven dollars for something that tastes like a candle.

What you are actually drinking

Most coffee-shop chai is not chai in the way your grandmother would recognize it. It's a concentrate, or a syrup pumped into steamed milk. The cardamom is a rumor. The clove is a suggestion. There is no whole spice in the cup — there is a flavor profile designed in a lab to remind you of a thing that was once real.

“It tastes like someone described chai to a machine and the machine tried its best.”

The seven-dollar math

Seven dollars. Plus tip. Plus the tip you add because the screen makes you feel guilty. For a drink that is mostly milk and a pump of syrup. I am not saying don't treat yourself. I am saying you could make the real thing at home, with actual whole spices, for a number so small per cup that I don't want to embarrass the coffee shop by saying it out loud.

AMMA SAYS

I'm not angry. I'm disappointed. There's a difference. One of them costs seven dollars.

What the real thing smells like

Here is the part the syrup can never replicate. When you simmer whole cardamom and ginger and cinnamon on your stove, your kitchen smells like someone's house. Not a store. A house. People walk in and say, 'What is that?' That reaction is free. The syrup pump has never once made anyone say 'What is that?' in a good way.

When friends come over

This is the real reason to make it yourself. Not the money, even though yes, the money. The reason is that when someone sits in your kitchen and you hand them a cup of chai made from real whole spices, they feel taken care of in a way a paper cup from a counter cannot replicate. Your friends deserve the cup that smells like a house.

THE TAKEAWAY

Buy the coffee. Make the chai. Call your Amma. In that order, or any order, just call her.

I will now step off my stool. But you know I'm right. You've always known. The cup at home is better, and it was never that hard. Now go put the kettle on.

GET AMMA'S UNSOLICITED ADVICE DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX.

Recipes, spice intel, and opinions nobody asked for. We only send the good stuff.

No spam. Only spicy updates, batch 01 pre-order alerts & recipes.